Case BE4174 · Famous breaches · L3 Applied

Should we pay the ransom?

Practise as: InterviewLevel: L3 Applied

Interview questionWe have been hit by ransomware and the board asks whether to pay. How do you advise them?

  1. 01 Answer
  2. 02 Example
  3. 03 Trade-offs
What a strong answer covers

Try it out loud first. Then check yourself:

  1. First establish facts: can backups restore critical systems, how long will it take, and what data was stolen?
  2. Legal limits: paying a sanctioned group can breach OFAC or similar rules; involve counsel, insurer and law enforcement early
  3. Paying buys a decryptor, not safety: Colonial's decryptor was so slow it restored from backups anyway
  4. Data deletion promises are worthless: Change Healthcare paid $22M, then a second group extorted it with the same data
  5. Trade-off: payment can save lives or the business, but funds future attacks; decide by downtime cost, safety and legality

If the interviewer pushes back

  • The FBI recovered part of Colonial's ransom. Does that change your advice, and why should you not count on it?

More Famous breaches cards

All Famous breaches cards →

cardosec draws a security topic and gives you a clock: explain it out loud with no notes, then see what you covered and what you missed. Free during early access.

Reviewed 2026-10-09